Tackling the Conundrums of Constant Expressions

Tackling the Conundrums of Constant Expressions

onstant expressions are tricky. Not all of them have an overt const qualifier. Furthermore, in some cases, a const-qualified variable is just a constant, but not a constant expression. These nuances aren’t just bits of C++ trivia. Rather, they affect the correctness of your code and its performance. The following sections explain the rules of constant integral expressions and show how to avert common mishaps.


How do you know whether an expression is a constant expression? How do you turn a non-constant expression into a constant expression when necessary?


Learn the rules of constant integral expressions.

In the following cases, C++ requires expressions that evaluate to an integral constant expression:

Contrary to popular conception, not every const variable of an integral type is a constant expression. Consider the following two examples:

struct C{ inline static int getval() {return 4;}};const int MAX=1024;const int MIN=C::getval();

Both MAX and MIN are constants, eg., the program can’t modify their values. However, there is a substantial difference between them. MAX is a constant integral expression. As such, it can be used in an array declaration, case labels, etc.:

char buff[MAX];int sizes=getsizes();switch (sizes){case MAX://.. break;default://.. break;};

What about MIN? Syntactically speaking, it’s a const object with an initializer, just as MAX is. However, if you try to use MIN in places where an integral constant expression is required, your compiler will complain:

struct bitpattern{ signed nibble: MIN;//error: constant expression required unsigned octet: 8; };enum SIZES { S=MIN, //error: constant expression required L=512,  XL=MAX //fine};

In the examples above, a compilation error reveals that MIN isn’t a constant expression. In fact, this is your litmus test: use a constant as an enumerator’s initializer to check whether it’s a valid constant expression.

Compile-time Evaluation
In time critical applications, constants are often chosen for performance reasons i.e., to ensure compile time evaluation of expressions. MIN can be evaluated at compile-time if C::getval() is inlined (every decent compiler will inline the call anyway). Thus, performance-wise, MIN and MAX are equally efficient. However, MIN isn’t an integral constant expression even when C::getval() is inlined since the rules of constant integral expressions are very strict. To qualify as a constant expression, MIN‘s initializer must be one of the following:

  • A literal such as 5, 8ul, ‘z’, and false
  • An enumerator
  • A sizeof expression
  • A const static data member initialized with a constant expression

To turn MIN into a constant expression, it’s therefore necessary to replace the C::getval() call with a literal. If you’re concerned about the maintenance problems that hard-coded literals might incur, use a macro instead. Yes, in spite of the fair criticism that macros often attract, they are still useful in some cases, so to speak:

#ifndef C_GETVAL#define C_GETVAL 4#endifconst int MIN=C_GETVAL;

Lo and behold, MIN is now a valid constant expression:

enum SIZES { S=MIN, //now OK L=512,  XL=MAX //fine};

Const Static Data Members
const static data members initialized by a constant expression require special attention. Seemingly, the recursive definition ensures that every const static member whose initializer is a constant expression is also a valid constant expression. This isn’t always true, though. Consider the following counter example:

struct C{ const static int X;};const int Y=C::X;const int C::X=2; //initialized by a constant expression

The static member X is initialized with a literal. The constant Y looks as a constant expression because its initializer C::X is seemingly a constant expression. Well, not quite:

char arr[Y];//error, constant expression required

Actually, neither C::X nor Y is a constant expression! The order of their definitions makes all the difference. The definition of Y uses C::X as the initializer but at this point, C::X hasn’t been defined yet. Consequently, the static initialization of Y is silently replaced with dynamic initialization, which means that Y is no longer a constant expression. Replacing the order of the definitions fixes this mess:

 const int C::X=2;  const int Y=C::X;//Y is now a constant expressionchar arr1[Y], arr2[C::X] //OK

Of course, you can eliminate such mishaps by using in-class initialization:

struct C{ const static int X=2;};

This will guarantee that C::X is a constant expression.

A Programmer’s Best Friend
The standards committee is now working on a mechanism that will allow programmers to use inline functions as initializers of constant expressions (further information on this proposal is available here). However, for the time being, you can use a macro?unsavory as this may seem.

With respect to const static data members of an integral type, the best policy is to use in-class initializers. However, older compilers don’t support in-class initializations. If you’re using such a compiler, always initialize const static members before using them or better yet, replace them with nameless enums.

To check whether your constants qualify as constant expressions, use them as initializers of dummy enumerators. This way your loyal compiler becomes the “constant expression watchdog”, alerting you whenever an expression that should be a constant expression isn’t really so.

devx-admin

devx-admin

Share the Post:
AI Software Development

ChatGPT is Now Making Video Games

Pietro Schirano’s foray into using ChatGPT, an AI tool for programming, has opened up new vistas in game and software development. As design lead at

Llama Codebot

Developers! Here’s Your Chatbot

Meta Platforms has recently unveiled Code Llama, a free chatbot designed to aid developers in crafting coding scripts. This large language model (LLM), developed using

Tech Layoffs

Unraveling the Tech Sector’s Historic Job Losses

Throughout 2023, the tech sector has experienced a record-breaking number of job losses, impacting tens of thousands of workers across various companies, including well-established corporations

Chinese 5G Limitation

Germany Considers Limiting Chinese 5G Tech

A recent report has put forth the possibility that Germany’s Federal Ministry of the Interior and Community may consider limiting the use of Chinese 5G

Modern Warfare

The Barak Tank is Transforming Modern Warfare

The Barak tank is a groundbreaking addition to the Israeli Defense Forces’ arsenal, significantly enhancing their combat capabilities. This AI-powered military vehicle is expected to

AI Software Development

ChatGPT is Now Making Video Games

Pietro Schirano’s foray into using ChatGPT, an AI tool for programming, has opened up new vistas in game and software development. As design lead at business finance firm Brex, Schirano

Llama Codebot

Developers! Here’s Your Chatbot

Meta Platforms has recently unveiled Code Llama, a free chatbot designed to aid developers in crafting coding scripts. This large language model (LLM), developed using Meta’s Llama 2 model, serves

Tech Layoffs

Unraveling the Tech Sector’s Historic Job Losses

Throughout 2023, the tech sector has experienced a record-breaking number of job losses, impacting tens of thousands of workers across various companies, including well-established corporations and emerging startups in areas

Chinese 5G Limitation

Germany Considers Limiting Chinese 5G Tech

A recent report has put forth the possibility that Germany’s Federal Ministry of the Interior and Community may consider limiting the use of Chinese 5G technology by local network providers

Modern Warfare

The Barak Tank is Transforming Modern Warfare

The Barak tank is a groundbreaking addition to the Israeli Defense Forces’ arsenal, significantly enhancing their combat capabilities. This AI-powered military vehicle is expected to transform the way modern warfare

AI Cheating Growth

AI Plagiarism Challenges Shake Academic Integrity

As generative AI technologies like ChatGPT become increasingly prevalent among students and raise concerns about widespread cheating, prominent universities have halted their use of AI detection software, such as Turnitin’s

US Commitment

US Approves Sustainable Battery Research

The US Department of Energy has revealed a $325 million commitment in the research of innovative battery types, designed to enable solar and wind power as continuous, 24-hour energy sources.

Netanyahu Musk AI

Netanyahu and Musk Discuss AI Future

On September 22, 2023, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu met with entrepreneur Elon Musk in San Francisco prior to attending the United Nations. In a live-streamed discussion, Netanyahu lauded Musk

Urban Gardening

Creating Thriving Cities Through Urban Gardening

The rising popularity of urban gardening is receiving increased recognition for its numerous advantages, as demonstrated in a recent study featured in the Environmental Research Letters journal. Carried out by

What You Need to Know About Cloud Security Strategies

What You Need to Know About Cloud Security Strategies

Today, many businesses are adopting cloud computing services. As a result, it’s important to recognize that security measures for data in the cloud are different from those in traditional on-premises

Romanian Energy Security

Eastern Europe is Achieving Energy Security

Canada and Romania have solidified their commitment to energy security and independence from Russian energy exports by signing a $3-billion export development agreement. The deal is centered on constructing two

Seamless Integration

Unlocking Seamless Smart Home Integration

The vision of an intelligently organized and interconnected smart home that conserves time, energy, and resources has long been desired by many homeowners. However, this aspiration has often been hindered

New Algorithm

MicroAlgo’s Groundbreaking Algorithm

MicroAlgo Inc. has revealed the creation of a knowledge-augmented backtracking search algorithm, developed through extensive research in evolutionary computational techniques. The algorithm is designed to boost problem-solving effectiveness, precision, and

Poland Energy Future

Westinghouse Builds Polish Power Plant

Westinghouse Electric Company and Bechtel have come together to establish a formal partnership in order to design and construct Poland’s inaugural nuclear power plant at the Lubiatowo-Kopalino site in Pomerania.

EV Labor Market

EV Industry Hurting For Skilled Labor

The United Auto Workers strike has highlighted the anticipated change towards a future dominated by electric vehicles (EVs), a shift which numerous people think will result in job losses. However,

Soaring EV Quotas

Soaring EV Quotas Spark Battle Against Time

Automakers are still expected to meet stringent electric vehicle (EV) sales quotas, despite the delayed ban on new petrol and diesel cars. Starting January 2023, more than one-fifth of automobiles

Affordable Electric Revolution

Tesla Rivals Make Bold Moves

Tesla, a name synonymous with EVs, has consistently been at the forefront of the automotive industry’s electric revolution. The products that Elon Musk has developed are at the forefront because

Sunsets' Technique

Inside the Climate Battle: Make Sunsets’ Technique

On February 12, 2023, Luke Iseman and Andrew Song from the solar geoengineering firm Make Sunsets showcased their technique for injecting sulfur dioxide (SO₂) into the stratosphere as a means

AI Adherence Prediction

AI Algorithm Predicts Treatment Adherence

Swoop, a prominent consumer health data company, has unveiled a cutting-edge algorithm capable of predicting adherence to treatment in people with Multiple Sclerosis (MS) and other health conditions. Utilizing artificial

Personalized UX

Here’s Why You Need to Use JavaScript and Cookies

In today’s increasingly digital world, websites often rely on JavaScript and cookies to provide users with a more seamless and personalized browsing experience. These key components allow websites to display

Geoengineering Methods

Scientists Dimming the Sun: It’s a Good Thing

Scientists at the University of Bern have been exploring geoengineering methods that could potentially slow down the melting of the West Antarctic ice sheet by reducing sunlight exposure. Among these

why startups succeed

The Top Reasons Why Startups Succeed

Everyone hears the stories. Apple was started in a garage. Musk slept in a rented office space while he was creating PayPal with his brother. Facebook was coded by a