Opinion:
Did Java Get Jilted by Latest Appeals Court Ruling?

Opinion:
Did Java Get Jilted by Latest Appeals Court Ruling?

hanks to the latest judicial ruling in the Microsoft Corp. case, it seems the world won’t be getting a pair of Baby Bills any time soon. Between Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson’s perceived ethical problems in discussing the case with reporters prior to a final ruling, and the appellate court’s ruling that Microsoft didn’t try to monopolize the browser market, it looks like Microsoft will stay intact. Sure, the appeals court upheld that Microsoft holds a monopoly with its Windows operating system. And it also found that Microsoft violated the Sherman Antitrust Act in trying to crush the Netscape Navigator browser and subvert Sun Microsystems’ Java technologies. But the necessary remedy isn’t a breakup.

But that doesn’t mean that there aren’t significant issues raised by the decision that Java developers should be aware of. For starters, though the Sun vs. Microsoft case was settled for $20 million back in January, the federal antitrust case could actually open up Microsoft to a private antitrust lawsuit from Sun. However, despite the temptation of a potential windfall, I doubt a corp-to-corp antitrust lawsuit will happen, given the effort necessary to prove damages.

The real meat of interest to the Java developer starts on Page 52 of the U.S. Court of Appeals ruling. Section 5 of the ruling reflects on the four areas of confusion Microsoft created in the marketplace in relation to Java:

  • the incompatible virtual machine
  • agreements with third-party vendors
  • deception of Java developers, and
  • threat to Intel.
  • In each area of reflection, the court confirms or denies monopolistic actions.

    JVM Anticompetitive But Not Monopolistic
    In the case of Microsoft’s Java virtual machine, the appeals court found that while the incompatible JVM was anticompetitive, it wasn’t monopolistic, reversing the district court’s strike against Microsoft. In essence, the appeals court said that the competitive justification for the incompatibilities?making “a large investment of engineering resources to develop a high-performance Windows JVM”?was sufficient to refute monopolistic practices.

    The second area where Microsoft was deemed to act in a monopolistic manner was in what the district court called “First Wave Agreements.” These were agreements with independent software vendors (ISVs), such as Rational and Symantec, to develop products reliant on Windows-specific technologies and to prevent them from delivering Sun-compatible JVMs. In this second area, the appeals court’s findings were mixed. Essentially, they rejected that Microsoft low-balled the pricing of the agreements. However, they did find that these agreements prevented distribution of “a Windows JVM that complied with Sun’s standards.” Since there was no pro-competitive justification for those provisions of the agreements, the fact that they required the use of the Microsoft VM was deemed a violation of the Sherman Act. Strike one.

    Area three is the one directly involving Java developers. It has to do with Microsoft’s deception of developers by delivering Visual J++. In and of itself, J++ wasn’t a bad thing. What was bad was that the programs created with it could inadvertently be Windows-specific because of the introduction of new language keywords and compiler directives (and their reliance on COM objects, though that specifically wasn’t mentioned in the latest ruling). Was that a bad thing? In and of itself, letting developers create Windows-specific programs wasn’t bad enough. What the courts found troublesome was the fact that Microsoft was two-faced. While Microsoft was publicly committing to cooperation with Sun, they led developers to believe they were creating cross-platform applications, when in fact they weren’t. According to the ruling:

    developers who relied upon Microsoft’s public commitment to cooperate with Sun and who used Microsoft’s tools to develop what Microsoft led them to believe were cross-platform applications ended up producing applications that would run only on the Windows operating system

    And that two-facedness is where the appellate court found Microsoft’s conduct “exclusionary.”

    As we all know, especially with the disappearance of Visual J++ as a development option, programs developed with J++ were more than likely not cross-platform?especially if you created them visually with the tool. With various references to internal Microsoft documents about polluting the Java market, the appeals court upheld the district court’s ruling that the exclusionary conduct was in violation of the Sherman Act. Strike two.

    Against Cross-Platform Development?
    The fourth and final area has to do with something I always suspected but could never prove. Well, at least not until the district court released its Finding of Fact. Did Microsoft use its “monopoly power to prevent firms such as Intel from aiding in the creation of cross-platform interfaces”? With plenty of evidence?such as Microsoft threatening to support AMD if Intel kept up its multimedia API support?the appeals court agreed with the district court in finding that Microsoft acted in a monopolistic fashion, yet again in violation of the Sherman Act. Strike three.

    Even with three strikes, Microsoft isn’t out. With several of the district court’s findings vacated and thanks to Judge Jackson’s foot-in-mouth behavior, the appeals court obliterated the potential for a breakup. While it was fun to read some of Jackson’s quotes, the appeals court’s summary has little immediate affect on the Java arena. If anything, it diminishes the district court’s conclusion, because it threw out one of the four earlier findings and reduced a second.

    At least Visual J++ is off the scene already. And so far, possibly with the help of Microsoft’s $20 million settlement, Sun has been able to avoid layoffs, even if most of the company was forced to take off the week of July 4. Now, if only they can get that stock price back up.

    As far as Microsoft goes, if you read about some of their negotiation tactics with Windows XP and AOL, it appears to be back to its old monopolistic ways.

    devx-admin

    devx-admin

    Share the Post:
    AI Girlfriend Craze

    AI Girlfriend Craze Threatens Relationships

    The surge in virtual AI girlfriends’ popularity is playing a role in the escalating issue of loneliness among young males, and this could have serious

    AIOps Innovations

    Senser is Changing AIOps

    Senser, an AIOps platform based in Tel Aviv, has introduced its groundbreaking AI-powered observability solution to support developers and operations teams in promptly pinpointing the

    Malyasian Networks

    Malaysia’s Dual 5G Network Growth

    On Wednesday, Malaysia’s Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim announced the country’s plan to implement a dual 5G network strategy. This move is designed to achieve a

    Advanced Drones Race

    Pentagon’s Bold Race for Advanced Drones

    The Pentagon has recently unveiled its ambitious strategy to acquire thousands of sophisticated drones within the next two years. This decision comes in response to

    Important Updates

    You Need to See the New Microsoft Updates

    Microsoft has recently announced a series of new features and updates across their applications, including Outlook, Microsoft Teams, and SharePoint. These new developments are centered

    AI Girlfriend Craze

    AI Girlfriend Craze Threatens Relationships

    The surge in virtual AI girlfriends’ popularity is playing a role in the escalating issue of loneliness among young males, and this could have serious repercussions for America’s future. A

    AIOps Innovations

    Senser is Changing AIOps

    Senser, an AIOps platform based in Tel Aviv, has introduced its groundbreaking AI-powered observability solution to support developers and operations teams in promptly pinpointing the root causes of service disruptions

    Bebop Charging Stations

    Check Out The New Bebob Battery Charging Stations

    Bebob has introduced new 4- and 8-channel battery charging stations primarily aimed at rental companies, providing a convenient solution for clients with a large quantity of batteries. These wall-mountable and

    Malyasian Networks

    Malaysia’s Dual 5G Network Growth

    On Wednesday, Malaysia’s Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim announced the country’s plan to implement a dual 5G network strategy. This move is designed to achieve a more equitable incorporation of both

    Advanced Drones Race

    Pentagon’s Bold Race for Advanced Drones

    The Pentagon has recently unveiled its ambitious strategy to acquire thousands of sophisticated drones within the next two years. This decision comes in response to Russia’s rapid utilization of airborne

    Important Updates

    You Need to See the New Microsoft Updates

    Microsoft has recently announced a series of new features and updates across their applications, including Outlook, Microsoft Teams, and SharePoint. These new developments are centered around improving user experience, streamlining

    Price Wars

    Inside Hyundai and Kia’s Price Wars

    South Korean automakers Hyundai and Kia are cutting the prices on a number of their electric vehicles (EVs) in response to growing price competition within the South Korean market. Many

    Solar Frenzy Surprises

    Solar Subsidy in Germany Causes Frenzy

    In a shocking turn of events, the German national KfW bank was forced to discontinue its home solar power subsidy program for charging electric vehicles (EVs) after just one day,

    Electric Spare

    Electric Cars Ditch Spare Tires for Efficiency

    Ira Newlander from West Los Angeles is thinking about trading in his old Ford Explorer for a contemporary hybrid or electric vehicle. However, he has observed that the majority of

    Solar Geoengineering Impacts

    Unraveling Solar Geoengineering’s Hidden Impacts

    As we continue to face the repercussions of climate change, scientists and experts seek innovative ways to mitigate its impacts. Solar geoengineering (SG), a technique involving the distribution of aerosols

    Razer Discount

    Unbelievable Razer Blade 17 Discount

    On September 24, 2023, it was reported that Razer, a popular brand in the premium gaming laptop industry, is offering an exceptional deal on their Razer Blade 17 model. Typically

    Innovation Ignition

    New Fintech Innovation Ignites Change

    The fintech sector continues to attract substantial interest, as demonstrated by a dedicated fintech stage at a recent event featuring panel discussions and informal conversations with industry professionals. The gathering,

    Import Easing

    Easing Import Rules for Big Tech

    India has chosen to ease its proposed restrictions on imports of laptops, tablets, and other IT hardware, allowing manufacturers like Apple Inc., HP Inc., and Dell Technologies Inc. more time

    Semiconductor Stock Plummet

    Dramatic Downturn in Semiconductor Stocks Looms

    Recent events show that the S&P Semiconductors Select Industry Index seems to be experiencing a downturn, which could result in a decline in semiconductor stocks. Known as a key indicator

    Anthropic Investment

    Amazon’s Bold Anthropic Investment

    On Monday, Amazon announced its plan to invest up to $4 billion in the AI firm Anthropic, acquiring a minority stake in the process. This decision demonstrates Amazon’s commitment to

    AI Experts Get Hired

    Tech Industry Rehiring Wave: AI Experts Wanted

    A few months ago, Big Tech companies were downsizing their workforce, but currently, many are considering rehiring some of these employees, especially in popular fields such as artificial intelligence. The

    Lagos Migration

    Middle-Class Migration: Undermining Democracy?

    As the middle class in Lagos, Nigeria, increasingly migrates to private communities, a PhD scholar from a leading technology institute has been investigating the impact of this development on democratic

    AI Software Development

    ChatGPT is Now Making Video Games

    Pietro Schirano’s foray into using ChatGPT, an AI tool for programming, has opened up new vistas in game and software development. As design lead at business finance firm Brex, Schirano

    Llama Codebot

    Developers! Here’s Your Chatbot

    Meta Platforms has recently unveiled Code Llama, a free chatbot designed to aid developers in crafting coding scripts. This large language model (LLM), developed using Meta’s Llama 2 model, serves

    Tech Layoffs

    Unraveling the Tech Sector’s Historic Job Losses

    Throughout 2023, the tech sector has experienced a record-breaking number of job losses, impacting tens of thousands of workers across various companies, including well-established corporations and emerging startups in areas

    Chinese 5G Limitation

    Germany Considers Limiting Chinese 5G Tech

    A recent report has put forth the possibility that Germany’s Federal Ministry of the Interior and Community may consider limiting the use of Chinese 5G technology by local network providers

    Modern Warfare

    The Barak Tank is Transforming Modern Warfare

    The Barak tank is a groundbreaking addition to the Israeli Defense Forces’ arsenal, significantly enhancing their combat capabilities. This AI-powered military vehicle is expected to transform the way modern warfare

    AI Cheating Growth

    AI Plagiarism Challenges Shake Academic Integrity

    As generative AI technologies like ChatGPT become increasingly prevalent among students and raise concerns about widespread cheating, prominent universities have halted their use of AI detection software, such as Turnitin’s